A Very Simple Game

Menu

  • First Time Here?
    • About Us
    • Why Stats Matter
    • Follow/Contact/Support Us
  • Glossary
    • General Terms
    • Site-Specific Terms
    • Black Ink & Grey Ink
    • FIP & xFIP
    • HoF Monitor & HoF Standards
    • JAWS
    • OPS+ & wOBA
    • SaSlg
    • rWAR, fWAR, & WARP
    • wRC+
  • Methodology
    • The Sandlot Test
    • The Who’s Who Test
    • How We Use Defensive Metrics
    • Why Use WAR v. Other Stats?
    • Why Use wRC+ v. Other Stats?
    • Why use FIP & xFIP?
  • Underrated/Overrated
    • Underrated
    • Overrated
  • Rewrite the Past: Award Re-votes
    • American League MVP
    • American League Cy Young
    • National League MVP
    • National League Cy Young
  • Look to the Future
    • Award Predictions
    • Bouncebacks & Breakouts
    • Contract & Trade Evaluations
    • Team Forecasts
  • The Bleachers
    • Burning Questions
    • Quick Takes (Blog)
    • Top Nine Lists
    • What If?

American League MVP

Most Valuable Player – certainly the most contentious award in recent memory. Maybe the controversy is built into the award itself because each person is left to decide their own definition for “valuable.” Maybe that’s what also makes it so much fun to debate (it is fun, right?). We’ll look at big power numbers v. all-around contributors, players before their time, and the voters stuck in the past.

We will be staying somewhat within the “confines of history” with these, meaning that the “re-vote” will at least consider the original vote order. The biggest effect of this will be valuing position players more than starting pitchers – if we went simply off of the stats, starters would have won a lot more MVP awards and re-voting all of those would become boring.

Here are some of the American League MVP votes that should have gone differently.

Re-write the Past: 1987 American League MVP

A Very Simple Game American League MVP, Rewrite the Past
Re-write the Past: 1987 American League MVP

Short Story: In 1987, garish power numbers helped Blue Jays’ LF George Bell edge out Tigers SS Alan Trammell for the American League MVP. The bad news? Bell was – at best – the 5th most valuable player in the AL that season. Read more

Best of A Very Simple Game

  • Top Nine Seasons by Players 40 and Older
  • Burning Question: Who was the Most Average Major League Player of All-time?
  • Ken Griffey Jr.’s Decline was Unique

Recent Articles

  • Jacob DeGrom should win the 2018 NL Cy YoungNL Cy Young Prediction: DeGrom should be the death blow to pitcher wins
  • 2018 Hall of Fame Ballot Rundown
  • Underrated? Is Mike Mussina a Hall of Famer?
  • Justin Verlander should have won at least one more Cy Young with the Tigers
  • By Keith Allison from Hanover, MD, USA (Jose Altuve) [CC BY-SA 2.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0)], via Wikimedia CommonsJose Altuve’s surprising weakness (one of the few)…
  • Tim Raines Montreal Expos Hall of FamerTim Raines, ‘Greatest Base Stealer Ever’? Not as crazy as it sounds.
  • Ivan Rodgriguez talking with pitcher for the Tigers, July 11, 2005. Photo by Googie Man 18:35, 11 July 2005Yes, Ivan Rodriguez was really *that* good defensively
  • Jeff Bagwell: An all-time great batting eye
  • Aaron JudgeAaron Judge and Baseball’s “Youth Movement”
  • Top Nine Seasons by Players 40 and Older

Site Search

Articles by Category

Search the Site

Copyright © 2025 A Very Simple Game.